Site Meter Media Criticism » Blog Archive » Friday roundup - Iraq, FCC, Troy Smith

Friday roundup - Iraq, FCC, Troy Smith

by Staff Writer

The big news in political journalism this week is the release of the Iraq Study Group report. There is some excellent commentary on this to be found, but you have to dig around for it. Media Matters, which specializes in cutting through conservative misinformation, has identified six findings in the report that the mainstream media seems to have overlooked:

They include: that the Pentagon has significantly underreported the extent of violence in Iraq, that U.S. officials possess little knowledge about the sources of the ongoing attacks, and that the situation in Afghanistan has grown so dire that U.S. troops may need to be diverted there from Iraq.

I feel like Claude Rains in Casablanca when I say that I am shocked that the mainstream media would not trumpet these findings. But at least Rolling Stone’s Matt Taibbi continues to provide the type of analysis that the dailies just don’t seem capable of:

That Iraq Report? More of the Same
The great Baker-Hamilton crock: A classic bullshit-cloud in the proud tradition of congressional “studies”
MATT TAIBBI

Taibbi cuts through the BS with refreshingly frank pearls of wisdom about American politics such as:

The successful politician today is the one who can best convert the agendas of his campaign contributors into politically saleable policies. That’s the business of government today; both the legislative and the executive branch are mainly engaged in searching out and finding the acceptable mean between voter sentiment and financial interest. It’s sort of an ongoing math problem — figuring out how many voters you can afford to fuck every four years, or how much money you should be extracting, and from which sponsors, for each rape of your constituents.

You just don’t ever read anything like that in the Washington Post. But Taibbi’s just getting warmed up:

And so, when faced with an unsolvable or seemingly unsolvable political conundrum, most politicians feel there’s only one thing to do. You appear onstage with your rival party’s leader, embrace him, announce that you’re going to find a “bipartisan” solution together, and then nominate a panel of rotting political corpses who will spend 18 months, a few dozen million dollars, many thousands of taxpayer-funded air miles, and about 130,000 pages of impossibly verbose text finding a way for both parties to successfully take the fork in the road and blow off the entire issue, whatever it was.

It’s important, when you nominate your panel, to dig up the oldest, saggiest, rubberiest, most used-up political whores on the Eastern seaboard to take up your cause. That way, you can be sure that the panel will know its place and not address any extraneous issues in its inquiry — like, for instance, whose fault a certain war is, or whether the whole idea of a “War on Terrorism” needs to be rethought, or whether the idea of preemptive defense as a general strategy is viable at all, or whether previously unthinkable solutions may now have to be countenanced, or whether there is anyone currently in a position of responsibility who perhaps should immediately be removed from office and hung by his balls. Your panel should contain people who are not experts or interested parties in the relevant field (since experts or interested parties might be tempted to come up with real, i.e. politically dangerous solutions), but it should contain people who are recognizable political celebrities whose names will lend weight to your whole enterprise, although not for any logical reason.

Baker-Hamilton was a classic whore-panel in every sense. None were Middle East experts. None had logged serious time in Iraq, before or after the invasion.

Prose like that offers hope for the future of journalism, but it’s sad that Rolling Stone seems to be the only print media outlet that will currently let someone like Taibbi channel the ghost of Hunter S. Thompson in modern reportings. And the newspaper business wonders why young people don’t read their middle-of-the-road rags?

Meanwhile, FreePress.net is urging us all to beware that the FCC is once again looking to sell out the public interest in favor of a sweetheart mega-merger for corporate monsters AT&T and BellSouth:

The FCC is at it again, ignoring the public interest to give handouts to massive corporations. This time, Chairman Kevin Martin has thrown the FCC’s ethics out the window to speed the mega-merger of BellSouth and AT&T before the incoming Congress can provide oversight.

Martin is forcing one commissioner, Robert McDowell, to overlook a conflict of interest and rubber stamp the AT&T merger without safeguards for Net Neutrality — the longstanding principle that prevents Internet providers from discriminating between Web sites. This move could undermine basic freedoms for all Internet users.

If you’re not familiar with the importance of the net neutrality issue, click here to read more about it.

Click here to send an email to your congressmen asking them to take action against this.

Moving on, my fellow Cleveland native Troy Smith, quarterback for the best damn football team in the land, will win the Heisman Trophy at the Manhattan Athletic Club tomorrow. ESPN.com’s Pat Forde has penned a great story about what a long and winding road Smith had to traverse to get to this point:

Pride will pulse throughout a village of legal guardians and guardian angels who raised this child, helping him from the mean streets of Cleveland to the bright lights of Manhattan — and, ultimately, beyond. But even with all the assistance, the kid had to take the hardest, loneliest steps of this climb himself.

When you consider where Troy Smith came from to reach this point, hero fits. And heroic describes his journey.

Smith, mom to share heartwarming moment of triumph
Forde
By Pat Forde
ESPN.com

Finally, Mel Gibson’s Apocalypto, a historical epic about the decline of the ancient Maya, hits theaters today. As an aficionado of the ancient Maya and their intriguing galactic calendar which ends on December 21, 2012, I have been looking forward to this film for some time. Early reviews appear mixed. I will check out the flick this weekend and report back soon…


Leave a Reply


About Media Criticism

Media Criticism takes a critical look at the media's coverage of news, politics, celebrities, and current events. It is not intended as a replacement for traditional media; rather, it is an analytical lens through which mainstream journalism can be viewed.

Media Criticism Author(s)
    » Nicholas-Katers

Politics & News Channel Posts

  • "Uncle Tom"?
    Ralph Nader Calls Obama "Uncle Tom"? Video And Transcript http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article21169.htm Fox News distorts Nader's comments to paint him as a racist Posted [...]
  • Market Mayhem
    Read on Progressive Talk: Markets on Fire By Mumia Abu-Jamal As stocks fall around the U.S., in Europe and in Asia, the dreaded "R" word and the "D" word can now be said aloud. Recession. [...]
  • Center-Right Socialism
    THE PROGRESSIVE POPULIST: A JOURNAL FROM THE HEARTLAND December 1, 2008 -- Volume 14, Number 21 http://www.populist.com EDITORIAL Center-Right Socialism Who was not moved by the sight of [...]
  • On Intelligent Design and the Left
    Cats, Dogs and Creationism By JEAN BRICMONT “The criticism of religion is the prerequisite of all criticism.” --Karl Marx (Introduction to A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s [...]
  • Rural-Urban Divide and Election '08
    The following article was published earlier this year on the website of the History News Network. A Historian Reflects on the Rural-Urban Divide and Election '08 By Daniel Herman March, [...]
  • Wind Turbine Artists Needed
    Drive east along Highway 50 toward South Lake Tahoe, California and you'll spot some unusual looking pine trees among the tall timbers of the Sierra Nevada Mountains. In fact these aren't trees at [...]
  • Worse than 9/11?
    Posted in Progressive Talk: London-based Arabic language newspaper Al-Quds Al-Arabi is reporting indications from a Yemeni with "very close" al-Qaeda ties that Osama bin Laden is plotting an [...]
  • Sold: Neverland Ranch
    Michael Jackson, recording artist and entertainer, has reportedly sold his child-like fantasy home The Neverland Ranch in Santa Barbara, California (120 Miles Northwest of Los Angeles) for $35 [...]
  • Obama's Impending Tax Increases
    From the right: It's happened. If you're like me, the worst case scenario is being played out in your mind. It's over. With Barack Obama as President, your finances are in bigger trouble [...]
  • Colorado Marijuana Reform Seminar and Activist Boot Camp
    On November 15, SAFER is co-hosting the Colorado Marijuana Reform Seminar and Activist Boot Camp at Regis University in Denver. The first-of-its-kind event is designed to immediately bolster [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Next Up: NCAA Championships
    No. 24 Arkansas Razorback men's cross country will run at the NCAA Championships, Mon., Nov. 24. [...]
  • So, let's talk about the runner-up
    Listen, I don't know what those folks over there at People were thinking but it certainly wasn't anywhere along the same lines as me.  I mean, Daniel Craig is a Bond man and he has those [...]
  • Silver Giveaway
    Christmas has always been perceived as the season for giving and receiving. ‘Guess it’s no wonder why this is the time of the year when people all around the world is in unison when it [...]
  • Vogue scans, and the New York Times
    The December issue of Vogue has hit stands and with that, I have the scans! Jen looks gorgeous in the photos and comes off beautifully in the interview. Thumbnails are [...]
  • Albuquerque NM Film office
    [caption id="attachment_796" align="alignnone" width="480" caption="Hey, just about anyone can work films in NM...."][/caption] Well not anybody, however the State of NM really keeps offering [...]

  • [caption id="attachment_1225" align="alignnone" width="300" caption="Santa Fe Dreaming..."][/caption] Ok this is a funky site that you must go visit,please, if you want to catch the wave (in a [...]
  • people never change
    There is an Introductory Address in the third edition of Domestic Cookery, Useful Receipts, And Hints to Young Housekeepers. by Elizabeth E. Lea. She also claims that "The Source of Liberal [...]
  • Albuquerque dances all night long? T or F?
    [caption id="attachment_47" align="alignnone" width="300" caption="OK OK, I'll go and listen to some music!"][/caption] Almost all night long. Here's some other event news from ABQarts.org [...]
  • Know Your Noxious Weeds and Invasive Species: Giant Hogweed
    It is true that I am a nerd that enjoys the study of nature and all of its creatures, and part and parcel of living in Portland, Oregon is enjoying nature. So today, I will bring you the fruit of my [...]
  • More Good Ratings
    [caption id="attachment_619" align="aligncenter" width="500" caption="Photo from DaemonsTV.com"][/caption] Criminal Minds was the #2 show in Canada this week, according to the Canadian Press. [...]