Site Meter Media Criticism » Blog Archive » It Is Not Either/Or

It Is Not Either/Or

by Carolyn Grismore

037_pnt_washdc.jpg

Politicians are pretty clever. If you listen to the way the current immigration debate is reported in the media you would believe that there are only two alternative: round up and deport 14-20 million illegals or grant them all immediate amnesty. The press doesn’t seem to question these assumptions and you hear them repeated every day.

This debate is coming at the problem from the wrong end. If I were being asked what to do with all the illegals here my answer would be absolutely nothing. That’s not where you begin addressing the problem. It might be where you end up, but it’s not where you begin. First, for national security reasons, you secure the borders and the ports. When that is done, you simultaneously begin fixing the broken legal immigration system, and cracking down on the employers who hire illegals with stiff fines and stiffer jail sentences. It will take maybe 3-4 well publicized cases before people will be too afraid to hire an illegal. It won’t be worth it.

Then get the legal ID system in place and begin handing them out to those who are now getting here legally much faster thanks to the new system. Require that the new ID card be presented for schools and all social services. Then just wait. After a couple of years when wages reach an equilibrium, assess the situation and determine if we really need more workers. If we do, then by all means design and implement a program to bring them in.

So what about all the illegals, I can hear you asking. Nothing. By this time they will have already begun self-deporting for lack of jobs. It’s a common mistake to assume these people come here because they want to be Americans. They come here because they want jobs. Most have no intention of ever assimilating. Dry up their jobs and they will go home. Once that’s done, then it’s going to be a simple job to round up and deport the remnants as you find them.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


Posted in General on June 12th, 2007

Link to this Entry

Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • No related posts

Leave a Reply


About Media Criticism

Media Criticism takes a critical look at the media's coverage of news, politics, celebrities, and current events. It is not intended as a replacement for traditional media; rather, it is an analytical lens through which mainstream journalism can be viewed.

Media Criticism Author(s)
    » Nicholas-Katers

NAVIGATE

LINKS

CATEGORIES

TOP COMMENTERS

RECENT COMMENTS

SUBSCRIBE

ARCHIVES

Politics & News Channel Posts

  • Frightening...
    From Films for Action: Thousands of Troops Are Deployed on U.S. Streets Ready to Carry Out "Crowd Control" By Naomi Wolf, From AlterNet.org Posted on October 8, 2008 Background: the First [...]
  • Selling Mortgages Like Credit Cards
    Families used to spend years saving up enough money to purchase a home in the United States. Only buyers with a 10% down payment and an excellent credit rating qualified. But in the last decade [...]
  • Pope Announces India's First Woman Saint
    India's Christians have something to celebrate today: At St. Peter's Square Pope Benedict XVI declared four new saints to the Roman Catholic church including an Indian woman. Her canonization is a [...]
  • Wake Up, America!
    A friend forwarded this youtube video: I love the original song, and I usually like a good parody, but the subject matter for this one is a little hard to take. Which led me to a few other [...]
  • Bailout Betrayal
    Dennis Kucinich on the Democrats' Bailout Betrayal Posted on Oct 5, 2008 - TruthDig.com By Chris Hedges The passing of the $850-billion bailout pulled the plug on the New Deal. The Great [...]
  • Michelle Obama: A real mother and wife
    I think Michelle Obama would make an excellent First Lady and I hope and dare to say, I think she will get that chance in just a few short weeks from now. I heard her really speak for the first [...]
  • Tent Cities Becoming Common Sight in United States
    From Radio Havana Cuba: Washington, October 3 (RHC)-- Throughout the United States, homeless advocacy groups and city agencies are reporting the most visible rise in homeless encampments -- or Tent [...]
  • Corporate Economy a Paper Tiger
    A letter to the editor the Cumberland Times-News published eight years ago from Jan D. Tuckley. The economy of the corporate capitalists is like a bicyclist who has ridden over a cliff. Unaware [...]
  • Rubber in the Road
    The pedestrians of Gardena, California have a little more spring in their step these days, and it has nothing to do with lighter wallets. Gardena's new rubber sidewalks are making the town more [...]
  • Chatter...
    From talk on the net ... People think that a banking or stock market collapse must be bad for everybody, but it's not. If you know a stock collapse is coming (because you are going to cause it) [...]

 

Hot Off The Press

  • Back in Action
    Scene: At our favourite local coffee shop. Mr. JM and I are sitting across from each other, he reading the newspaper and I thinking about various things as I stir my chai. In our hurry to get there [...]
  • Paris Hilton annoys Roxy Music frontman
    You cannot please everybody. For Paris Hilton’s case, it’s the majority she can’t please. Well after several Hollywood A-listers expressed their annoyance to our dear heiress’s [...]
  • Say hi to your mother for me, okay?
    Aw, look who doesn't have a sense of humor about himself. Good old Mark Mark (formerly of the Funky Bunch) has been in too many Academy Award-nominated movies and has produced too many Emmy-award [...]
  • I'm Very Lame
    I have all these great and fun photos of Timber and the other doggies but haven't yet uploaded them into my Flickr account. I also went to an amazing wedding on Saturday and MUST share it with all of [...]
  • Bound for Glory IV Jeff Jarett VS Kurt Angle - Video
    Bound 4 Glory IV Kurt Angle Vs Jeff Jarett 1/3 Bound 4 Glory IV Kurt Angle Vs Jeff Jarett 2/3 Bound 4 Glory IV Kurt Angle Vs Jeff Jarett 3/3 [...]
  • Supernaturally Gross
    "Well, that's gonna be . . . horrible." Dean's quote pretty much sums up Thursday's episode of Supernatural. No, wait, the episode was good, but it was also pretty gross and horrible. Dean did have [...]
  • Absentee ballots due by Nov. 1
    Mark Estelle is voting with an absentee ballot in the Nov. 4 election so he can remain a registered voter in his hometown. "I know people running for different offices, and I want to support them," [...]
  • Just forget about it!
    ...But where sin abounded, grace abounded much more, so that as sin reigned in death, even so grace might reign through righteousness to eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord. Romans [...]
  • The Four Reasons..or the Fourth One Anyway...Meg found it....
    Meg is guest posting for me while I drag myself together and figure out which way is up.  You can find her posting regular at her place, Get In, Hang on. When Jerri Ann asked me if I might do a [...]
  • Ode to Classic Rock & Converse (Celebrating the New Line of Rock n' Roll Inspired Shoes!)
    Journey's Shoe Retailer and Converse Shoes have teamed up to create a new line of shoes inspired by some of the best classic rock bands ever! Below is a short story written by Pop Culture Buzz [...]