Site Meter Media Criticism » Blog Archive » John McCain: The Proof that Pundits and Commentators Have No Value

John McCain: The Proof that Pundits and Commentators Have No Value

by Nicholas Katers

coulter.png

It is time to look at John McCain as the Republican nominee, no offense to Mike Huckabee and his valiant efforts on Super Tuesday. McCain was able to beat Mitt Romney and Huckabee in a diverse range of states from California to New Hampshire with the help of Republican voters. The fact that some independents voted for him is overblown considering the largesse of independents voting on the Democratic side of the ballot. Mitt Romney’s victories in places like Montana and Alaska along with Huckabee’s victories in Dixie don’t give the Republicans anything they don’t already have.

It is time for conservative pundits and commentators to realize that they have no value in helping the Republican Party. I will extend this beyond talking heads of the right to people on television who are dogmatic in their political beliefs. Ann Coulter saying that she would stump for Clinton instead of voting for McCain and Rush Limbaugh bloviating on about the destruction of the Republican Party show the ridiculous vacuum these “analysts� live within.

Imagine Ann Coulter running for Senate in whatever state she was spawned. It is difficult, isn’t it? Coulter emerging from the conservative coterie to debate a living, breathing Democrat who is experienced in dealing logically with alternative view points is unlikely in this lifetime. I cannot imagine Ann Coulter trying to glad-hand people for donations. I won’t even get into Rush Limbaugh’s limited potential as a candidate given his inability to stay on ESPN after comments about Donovan McNabb. These well-fed commentators know nothing of the challenges of the real world. They only know challenges to their narrow and previously untouched viewpoints that are as ridiculous as the platform of Lyndon Larouche.

The purpose of parties (and their advocates) is to represent a viewpoint unrepresented in the current political dialogue. The purpose of political leaders is to bring together multiple parties when possible to fix problems in an ad hoc manner. The reality is that political leaders ride parties until the realities of national politics make kowtowing unnecessary. Americans say they are sick of the two-party system but they are really sick of dogmatic party leaders. I think that the nominee for the Democrats and John McCain need to demonstrate that they are political leaders and not party leaders to amass any semblance of a mandate after January 2009.


Leave a Reply


About Media Criticism

Media Criticism takes a critical look at the media's coverage of news, politics, celebrities, and current events. It is not intended as a replacement for traditional media; rather, it is an analytical lens through which mainstream journalism can be viewed.

Media Criticism Author(s)
    » Nicholas-Katers

Politics & News Channel Posts

  • Frightening...
    From Films for Action: Thousands of Troops Are Deployed on U.S. Streets Ready to Carry Out "Crowd Control" By Naomi Wolf, From AlterNet.org Posted on October 8, 2008 Background: the First [...]
  • Selling Mortgages Like Credit Cards
    Families used to spend years saving up enough money to purchase a home in the United States. Only buyers with a 10% down payment and an excellent credit rating qualified. But in the last decade [...]
  • Pope Announces India's First Woman Saint
    India's Christians have something to celebrate today: At St. Peter's Square Pope Benedict XVI declared four new saints to the Roman Catholic church including an Indian woman. Her canonization is a [...]
  • Wake Up, America!
    A friend forwarded this youtube video: I love the original song, and I usually like a good parody, but the subject matter for this one is a little hard to take. Which led me to a few other [...]
  • Bailout Betrayal
    Dennis Kucinich on the Democrats' Bailout Betrayal Posted on Oct 5, 2008 - TruthDig.com By Chris Hedges The passing of the $850-billion bailout pulled the plug on the New Deal. The Great [...]
  • Michelle Obama: A real mother and wife
    I think Michelle Obama would make an excellent First Lady and I hope and dare to say, I think she will get that chance in just a few short weeks from now. I heard her really speak for the first [...]
  • Tent Cities Becoming Common Sight in United States
    From Radio Havana Cuba: Washington, October 3 (RHC)-- Throughout the United States, homeless advocacy groups and city agencies are reporting the most visible rise in homeless encampments -- or Tent [...]
  • Corporate Economy a Paper Tiger
    A letter to the editor the Cumberland Times-News published eight years ago from Jan D. Tuckley. The economy of the corporate capitalists is like a bicyclist who has ridden over a cliff. Unaware [...]
  • Rubber in the Road
    The pedestrians of Gardena, California have a little more spring in their step these days, and it has nothing to do with lighter wallets. Gardena's new rubber sidewalks are making the town more [...]
  • Chatter...
    From talk on the net ... People think that a banking or stock market collapse must be bad for everybody, but it's not. If you know a stock collapse is coming (because you are going to cause it) [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Back in Action
    Scene: At our favourite local coffee shop. Mr. JM and I are sitting across from each other, he reading the newspaper and I thinking about various things as I stir my chai. In our hurry to get there [...]
  • Paris Hilton annoys Roxy Music frontman
    You cannot please everybody. For Paris Hilton’s case, it’s the majority she can’t please. Well after several Hollywood A-listers expressed their annoyance to our dear heiress’s [...]
  • Say hi to your mother for me, okay?
    Aw, look who doesn't have a sense of humor about himself. Good old Mark Mark (formerly of the Funky Bunch) has been in too many Academy Award-nominated movies and has produced too many Emmy-award [...]
  • I'm Very Lame
    I have all these great and fun photos of Timber and the other doggies but haven't yet uploaded them into my Flickr account. I also went to an amazing wedding on Saturday and MUST share it with all of [...]
  • Bound for Glory IV Jeff Jarett VS Kurt Angle - Video
    Bound 4 Glory IV Kurt Angle Vs Jeff Jarett 1/3 Bound 4 Glory IV Kurt Angle Vs Jeff Jarett 2/3 Bound 4 Glory IV Kurt Angle Vs Jeff Jarett 3/3 [...]
  • Supernaturally Gross
    "Well, that's gonna be . . . horrible." Dean's quote pretty much sums up Thursday's episode of Supernatural. No, wait, the episode was good, but it was also pretty gross and horrible. Dean did have [...]
  • Absentee ballots due by Nov. 1
    Mark Estelle is voting with an absentee ballot in the Nov. 4 election so he can remain a registered voter in his hometown. "I know people running for different offices, and I want to support them," [...]
  • Just forget about it!
    ...But where sin abounded, grace abounded much more, so that as sin reigned in death, even so grace might reign through righteousness to eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord. Romans [...]
  • The Four Reasons..or the Fourth One Anyway...Meg found it....
    Meg is guest posting for me while I drag myself together and figure out which way is up.  You can find her posting regular at her place, Get In, Hang on. When Jerri Ann asked me if I might do a [...]
  • Ode to Classic Rock & Converse (Celebrating the New Line of Rock n' Roll Inspired Shoes!)
    Journey's Shoe Retailer and Converse Shoes have teamed up to create a new line of shoes inspired by some of the best classic rock bands ever! Below is a short story written by Pop Culture Buzz [...]